Connect with us

Politics

Judge refuses to accept ‘death wish’ list for oath guard in seditious conspiracy trial

Published

on

In J6th’s most important trial to date, US District Judge Mehta has refused to acknowledge evidence that Steward Rhodes, the leader of the Oaths, kept a “death list” on his writing notebook created just days before the attack on the Capitol. This may sound outrageous but, below, I’ll explain why it doesn’t exist and it’s a very strong ruling despite the inconvenience of the Department of Justice.

Judge Mehta listened to the full context in which the government wanted to add this evidence and found it dangerous. By making this ruling, it makes the case a little bit more difficult for the Department of Justice (a little bit), but it does solidify any case on appeal, and one of the first things an appellate attorney looks at coming out of trial is accepting highly inflammatory evidence that was not relevant to the elements. involved in the criminal trial.

Advertisement

If Mehta believed a death wish was necessary to prove the plot and was part of the January 6 plan, he would likely admit the evidence as it would be “very relevant”. But Mehta found that these were merely personal notes that Rhodes had taken on his own. As such, the evidence is somewhat relevant to Rhodes’ state of mind but not really the plot itself, the primary charge.

low link. But on top of this consideration is the fact that the list is highly inciting. No matter how many times defense attorneys say, “Holding to evidence as applied to a conspiracy, these were just speculations that were not acted upon…” it didn’t matter. A jury, like most of us, will hear the “death list” and it will stay in our brains as something like, “This guy is a monster,” and while that may be true, it has nothing to do with the charges. Low significance, highly inflammatory is a recipe to back off on appeal.

Why did the Ministry of Justice submit it knowing that it was an appeal case? They might argue on appeal that even if you give up that evidence, the real evidence is so overwhelming that it’s a harmless mistake. They will get a great latitude but not infinite.

Judge Mehta did what a good judge does, weighed the pros/cons of the evidence, and ruled in favor of the defendant.

My criminal law professor said, on the first day of L-school, “Remember, when we think about the criminal justice system, we don’t ask, ‘What do I want for them?’” No, the question is, “What would I want for myself if I was falsely accused or overcharged?” The people who founded this country were criminals. They set up a system to protect the law and protect themselves.”

Advertisement

It is a good point to consider Mehta’s judgment and interpretation.



Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Politics

Like-smiling trans daughter arrested for her father’s murder

Published

on

By

The suspect is Nikki Secondino

Reported expert portal regarding the killing of 61-year-old Carlo Scandino in his Brooklyn apartment Thursday in an incident that police initially indicated was a home invasion.

Sources at The New York Post indicated that the killer may have been closer to home, suggesting Secondino’s trans daughter may have been involved.

Advertisement

Carlo’s 22-year-old transgender daughter Nikki Scandino has been accused of killing her father.

Common: MUST READ: Corruption In Maricopa County 2022 And How Runbeck Used Spanish-Speaking Employees And Resignation Of Running Ballots On Election Day

Nikki smirked for the cameras as she was escorted out of the NYPD police station.

Photo: Facebook screenshot/Carlo Secondino

Advertisement

The New York Post reported:

Nikki Scandino has been charged with murder and other crimes after police initially believed her father, Carlo Secondino, had been stabbed to death during an early morning home invasion at their Bensonhurst home.

Sources told The Post earlier Thursday that Nicki is suspected of making up a fake break-in story to cover up her brutal crime.

But the tale quickly unraveled and the alleged killer was also charged with attempted murder and criminal possession of a weapon in connection with the horrific attack in which her 19-year-old sister was stabbed.

The younger sister was taken to Maimonides Hospital in critical condition.

Nikki smiled, but ignored reporters’ questions, as investigators led her out of Brooklyn’s 62nd Precinct Thursday night.

Advertisement

A neighbor of Secondinos also said she heard Nikki Make a phone call in the hallway after the murder, claiming that the family was robbed by home invaders, who also stabbed them.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Politics

Trump’s tax returns released by House Democrats

Published

on

By

The release of former President Donald J. Trump’s private tax documents comes amid questions about why the IRS failed to fully audit him during his presidency.

Source link

Continue Reading

Politics

Bolsonaro rules out military intervention in Brazil, “I have no support from other institutions to act against Lula!”

Published

on

By




JUST IN: Bolsonaro rules out military intervention in Brazil, “I have no support from other institutions to act against Lula!”


















Advertisement




quantast

Click here to add The Western Journal to your home screen.

// Load the SDK asynchronously (function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, "script", "facebook-jssdk"));

Source link

Continue Reading

Trending